One of the latest guest judges, former professional dancer Mark Ballas, has sparked conversations among fans about potential changes to the status quo—or at least an addition. Will Dancing with the Stars introduce a new judging panel in 2025? While Season 34 is still some time away, discussions about reshuffling the judges' lineup have already begun. The current panel, which has largely remained unchanged since the show's inception, might see modifications as producers consider fresh perspectives.
The Current Lineup: A Familiar Face-Off
Dancing with the Stars continues to captivate audiences under the hosting duo of Alfonso Ribeiro and Julianne Hough. Joining them are seasoned judges: Carrie Ann Inaba, Derek Hough, and Bruno Tonioli. Recently, it was confirmed that these three will return for another season, maintaining their positions at the judges' table. Over the course of 11 weeks, contestants collaborate with professional ballroom dancers to master various styles, all while vying for the coveted Mirrorball Trophy. Each week, one pair is eliminated based on a combination of judges' scores and public votes.
However, recent seasons have raised questions about scoring consistency. Fans have noticed an increase in mid-range scores—sevens and eights—that leave many puzzled. Some argue that celebrities should work harder to earn higher marks. Critics suggest that ABC's Dancing with the Stars Season 33 may have sacrificed authenticity by trading sharp critiques for inflated scores, thereby diminishing the competitive edge.
A Look Back: The Evolution of Judging Panels
Throughout its history, Dancing with the Stars has seen several notable figures grace the judges' table. Among them was Len Goodman, whose tenure on both the U.S. and U.K. versions of the show helped reignite interest in ballroom dancing globally. Recognized for his wit and expertise, Goodman received the Carl Alan Award for his outstanding contributions to dance. His legacy lives on through the show’s continued emphasis on technical skill and artistry.
But does longevity equate to effectiveness? As the series progresses, there's growing debate over whether rotating judges could invigorate the competition. Proponents believe introducing new voices would bring fresh insights and maintain audience engagement. Cheryl Burke, a former professional dancer who retired after 26 seasons, echoed this sentiment when she criticized the current panel for lacking sufficient expertise in traditional ballroom techniques. She urged them to educate themselves further.
Fans React: Is It Time for Change?
Some fans agree with Burke's assessment, suggesting that keeping certain judges consistent while occasionally swapping others could strike the right balance between familiarity and novelty. This approach might prevent stagnation and encourage more dynamic feedback. For instance, Stephen Nedoroscik, the 2024 Olympic double bronze medalist, delivered standout performances alongside partner Rylee Arnold, earning praise from all three judges. Yet, even such high-caliber acts deserve critical evaluations to push boundaries.
In interviews conducted live during news broadcasts, judges like Bruno Tonioli and Carrie Ann Inaba have shared their thoughts on evolving trends within the industry. Their input underscores the importance of staying relevant without compromising core values. Meanwhile, behind-the-scenes decisions, such as production rules governing judges' saves, continue to shape outcomes—and sometimes spark controversy.
Interactive Fun: Bringing the Magic Home
Beyond television screens, fans can now participate in the magic with printable Dancing with the Stars-themed judge's paddles. These interactive party supplies allow enthusiasts to mimic the excitement of scoring dances themselves. Available in vibrant purple and white designs, they serve as excellent conversation starters at gatherings celebrating the show.
As research from Professors Kieran O'Connor and Amar Cheema reveals, unconscious biases often influence ratings across various fields—from dance competitions to online reviews. Understanding these dynamics ensures fair assessments moving forward. Whether or not Dancing with the Stars embraces change in 2025 remains to be seen. What is certain, however, is that the world eagerly awaits what lies ahead for this beloved program.
